Kommentare zu: Six Claims for Digital History http://weblog.hist.net/archives/3502 Weblog zu Geschichte und Digitalen Medien Tue, 31 Jan 2012 21:09:15 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3.1 Von: Sześć tez o historii digitalnej « Historia i Media http://weblog.hist.net/archives/3502/comment-page-1#comment-57783 Sześć tez o historii digitalnej « Historia i Media Tue, 29 Jun 2010 23:23:29 +0000 http://weblog.histnet.ch/?p=3502#comment-57783 [...] angielską dokumentu pobrać można na tej stronie (wersja oryginalna dostępna jest tutaj). Poniżej udostępniam polskie tłumaczenie [...] [...] angielską dokumentu pobrać można na tej stronie (wersja oryginalna dostępna jest tutaj). Poniżej udostępniam polskie tłumaczenie [...]

]]> Von: Jan Hodel & Peter Haber http://weblog.hist.net/archives/3502/comment-page-1#comment-57422 Jan Hodel & Peter Haber Sun, 10 Jan 2010 22:36:49 +0000 http://weblog.histnet.ch/?p=3502#comment-57422 Hi Mills Thanks for your comment. You are right and you are pointing to an important detail. It was not our intention to make a distinction between analog and digital historians, actually. We see it more like two modes of performing the job as a historian: an analog and a digital mode that mix in different ratios depending on the individual interests and skills. Maybe even this sight is misleading in the long run - maybe we should rather talk about the work of the historians in the digital age - regardless wether they think of themselves being "analog" or "digital" historians. Because you cannot ignore that digital media have changed our academic world even if you don't take part in every detail of this change. Peter and Jan Hi Mills
Thanks for your comment. You are right and you are pointing to an important detail. It was not our intention to make a distinction between analog and digital historians, actually. We see it more like two modes of performing the job as a historian: an analog and a digital mode that mix in different ratios depending on the individual interests and skills. Maybe even this sight is misleading in the long run – maybe we should rather talk about the work of the historians in the digital age – regardless wether they think of themselves being “analog” or “digital” historians. Because you cannot ignore that digital media have changed our academic world even if you don’t take part in every detail of this change.
Peter and Jan

]]> Von: Mills Kelly http://weblog.hist.net/archives/3502/comment-page-1#comment-57412 Mills Kelly Sun, 27 Dec 2009 00:50:10 +0000 http://weblog.histnet.ch/?p=3502#comment-57412 Thanks for republishing these so that I can share them with my students here in the US. I'd like to take exception with one way that these are framed. As written, the Claims make it sound as though "digital historians" were somehow different from "analog historians" when it comes to the use of digital materials. I know very few analog historians who don't use digital materials and so I think it's more accurate and useful to say that these six claims apply to ALL historians. Mills Thanks for republishing these so that I can share them with my students here in the US.

I’d like to take exception with one way that these are framed. As written, the Claims make it sound as though “digital historians” were somehow different from “analog historians” when it comes to the use of digital materials. I know very few analog historians who don’t use digital materials and so I think it’s more accurate and useful to say that these six claims apply to ALL historians.

Mills

]]> Von: Lyonel Kaufmann http://weblog.hist.net/archives/3502/comment-page-1#comment-57404 Lyonel Kaufmann Mon, 21 Dec 2009 09:03:15 +0000 http://weblog.histnet.ch/?p=3502#comment-57404 Bonjour, L'article suivant, publié sur le site français du Café pédagogique, répercute vos six thèses: • Le Web plus efficace que la classe? (http://www.cafepedagogique.net/lemensuel/lenseignant/schumaines/histoire/Pages/2009/108_Lachronique.aspx) Cordialement, Lyonel Kaufmann Bonjour,
L’article suivant, publié sur le site français du Café pédagogique, répercute vos six thèses:
• Le Web plus efficace que la classe? (http://www.cafepedagogique.net/lemensuel/lenseignant/schumaines/histoire/Pages/2009/108_Lachronique.aspx)

Cordialement,

Lyonel Kaufmann

]]> Von: Lyonel Kaufmann http://weblog.hist.net/archives/3502/comment-page-1#comment-57401 Lyonel Kaufmann Thu, 17 Dec 2009 08:29:34 +0000 http://weblog.histnet.ch/?p=3502#comment-57401 Bonjour, Au moment de la publication de vos thèses en allemand, j'en avais effectué une traduction (approximative) ici: http://lyonelkaufmann.ch/histoire/2009/09/16/theses-sur-les-sciences-historiques-a-lere-digitale/ Vos remarques concernant ma traduction sont les bienvenues. Si vous souhaitez mettre cette traduction en français sur votre site, pas de problème non plus. A bientôt. Lyonel Kaufmann Bonjour,
Au moment de la publication de vos thèses en allemand, j’en avais effectué une traduction (approximative) ici: http://lyonelkaufmann.ch/histoire/2009/09/16/theses-sur-les-sciences-historiques-a-lere-digitale/

Vos remarques concernant ma traduction sont les bienvenues. Si vous souhaitez mettre cette traduction en français sur votre site, pas de problème non plus.

A bientôt.

Lyonel Kaufmann

]]>